Chaplains and Religious Liberty

Published October 21, 2006 - Glendale News Press - Los Angeles Time

IN THEORY

Chaplains and Religious Liberty

Q:

Secretary of the Navy Donald C. Winter reportedly issued instructions to Navy chaplains earlier this year that religious portions of events such as graduations or command changes should be "nonsectarian in nature" and that chaplains must "be willing to function in a pluralistic environment." The instructions have prompted a debate about whether a chaplain's ability to express his or her faith is justified in a secular setting and whether phrases such as "praying in Jesus' name" during an invocation could offend the ranks.The move has concerned members of Congress and evangelicals, who say that any restriction on religious liberty restricts their freedom of religion. They propose legislation that would allows chaplains to practice their faith, even in nonsectarian settings. What do you think? Do you think there should be such legislation? Or do you think the Navy secretary's direction was warranted?

A:

You can't have a "religious" portion to an event that is "nonsectarian." This violates definitions.

You certainly can ask a chaplain to be considerate of the various traditions present at an event, but all prayers conjure sectarian images.

Everyone has a unique set of beliefs. Religion is the expression of those beliefs. Even atheism involves a set of beliefs, if not in anything, at least in the self that is able to contemplate these thoughts. A chaplain is a person who represents a particular tradition with a unique set of instructions for expression.

Unfortunately, at many of public events, prayers and invocations are ceremonial and lack any depth or meaning. They are meant to showcase a particular allegiance by a politician or to appease a certain constituency. And in so doing, inevitably, someone is offended.

A true prayer cannot be offensive because it talks to the depths of the human experience. It conjures images of attainable dreams, such as peace and justice. It crosses all boundaries, sectarian, secular and denominational.

FR. VAZKEN MOVSESIAN
Armenian Church
In His Shoes Mission